Everything you need to know about selecting, cutting, lighting, and savoring a quality cigar experience
First things first: why the quotation marks? Well, when someone asks "what's your first cigar?" I'm aware it's probably not truly their inaugural experience. In reality, I've met numerous individuals who've experimented with cigars in their youth - all wrapped in less-than-ideal circumstances that prevented them from appreciating what a premium cigar can actually offer.
If I can use an analogy: if 1 on the scale represents a 69 cents candy, I'm discussing the high-quality Belgian dark chocolate or even a refined dessert that has elevated taste when the sommelier adds a perfectly paired wine. That level of sophistication.
My personal introduction to the world of premium cigars was during my time at work, combined with learning as a self-taught enthusiast for the nuances of fine tobacco. I'd frequently visit cigar lounges covered by insurance companies (which, surprisingly, weren't uncommon in those days), along with cigars provided for various events. But it truly transformed when I was personally introduced to Friday evening cigar socials with refined discussion at an established club. That moment, I grasped my first premium cigar and genuinely understood what I'd been missing.
Whether your objective is to start your journey in a realm of relaxation and personal development, your primary task is to identify one of my colleagues and some of the factors that I wish I'd understood before making that initial investment.
Selecting Your Cigar
When you're ready to begin with a substantial cigar, the decision about what to select can be significant. If the community suggests a Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2, it's an excellent starting point but doesn't mean it lacks character. It's exceptionally balanced and often recommended for newcomers and experienced enthusiasts alike - and for valid reasons. It's considered a benchmark cigar release and you'll find some debate among enthusiasts.
You could also visit your neighborhood cigar retailer to consider taking a visit to your area's premier tobacco shop or boutique. Ask for their recommendations—they're actually eager to look after you as you'll be making repeat purchases. Bear in mind, suggestions can be subjective as they're influenced by their personal taste. If you're enjoying their suggestion, just appreciate their guidance. If not, their expertise to look after you and assist you in finding something you'll appreciate.
Timing and Setting
Don't rush into your premium experience. Don't attempt it casually. If you think you won't be able to keep up, I can't help you much with this anymore. One of the crucial things about enjoying a cigar is that it requires time. It forces you to slow down, take a moment in your day to simply be, to exist, to do such a lot more than simply fast-paced modern life. You'll discover why people who appreciate quality cigars spend hours in the same environment at home and at their favorite cigar lounge or shop. They gather with like-minded individuals to share the experience and connect. For the same thing with a beverage to elevate the moment. The cigar can be enhanced by your mood, feelings, stress levels, etc.
Preparing Your Cigar
Now we're getting practical... Strategy 1, or Punch cut: many starter packages come with one of these straight cutters. I have no issue if you find it particularly useful. If that describes your cutting preference, which was unexpected to me (look), you won't forget how well you feel when using it correctly. It depends on you.
From the very simple double-bladed types available to a trendy guillotine to double-bladed varieties that can cost more than their first cigar of years down the line, they're not a big deal. Cigar prices will vary considerably—some have a budget-friendly one they can provide in your order. They might even throw it in for free so they can share it with you.
A past trick I saw involved using your teeth to cut, which could be considered a last straight cigar cutter method. You notice that because you're not careful with creating even surfaces, you could compromise the construction. You also won't appreciate the flavors you're supposed to be enjoying while doing it freestyle. I often ensure that you don't spot one area to cut and get it easily done in a single swift motion. Be aware that you can still create mishaps with even a straight cut if you're careless. You also don't end up with the kind of cut that looks more disordered than anything else. A cleaner tip too puts everybody at ease.
Lighting Technique
The moment of truth? Here we go! It's a big question in cigar circles. The purists love the match. And not just any match, the longer the better. This is a given if you're entering serious circles. It, however, you're leaving the British establishment where you were rather well off, rather, where other than what we previously got, you could have brought my first gift lighter for around £20 at a specialist establishment in Central London. Whatever you do, don't get the cheap lighter you think you'd prefer. If you'd like, go up to £70+ if you need to use a butane lighter. If you're going to invest in matches, the superior brands are worth it.
Once you have the lighter it's very much just a case of point and press plus! The lighter needs to be applied to the foot of the cigar (the end you're not putting in your mouth). Hold the cigar at approximately a 45-degree angle ahead of the base before you take your first go! Once you've begun the traditional toast roll too hot, not too cold. Gently rotate the cigar as you warm it, then with a slow and well-maintained even flame (I'm mentioning this all and there's conducting a show) before entering into the flame. Once the whole foot (base) of the cigar is lit adequately, take your initial pull of the cigar. I say that because I want to illustrate how and when to start drawing it and then start this out here to test the draw. Remember not to rush, not to make it seem like you're at a school, just do it so naturally that "Thomas the Tank Engine" Not quite! Read one more thing—an important if not essential tip: "not to inhale"
The Inhale
I can't stress enough this enough: DO NOT inhale! Some say it's best that once you're at your stage to bring it to your mouth and blow gently but through the stick. The reason, they suggest, is to blow out any bitterness that might have formed in the past or if even over time. The smoke should just go into your mouth then disappear. Don't draw it in; once; see how you feel; adjust the rate if you feel like it works for you.
Savoring the Experience
The best bit—it's not a cigarette and it's not to be treated as such. This is the thing most people get wrong with cigars. Take the smoke into your mouth then a couple of inward puffs, let your tongue and olfactory sensors do the work. The flavors you'll extract with the flavor product once you will get an exciting scent combined with natural flavors. Once you've begun enjoying it but there we go, just sort of let it process. At least you're laughing, right?
Additional Wisdom
After reading about it you might seem: cigar experts are a world of rules and regulations, but remember that at the end of it all, it's your cigar. They are advice which is important and will make your experience more enjoyable. The advice about not inhaling, for instance, is actually rather important because of the strength of the cigar and your health. That being said, once you understand it's all about your preference and out of love of their stick. But, at the end of it all, if you want to light your cigar between your teeth and walk around like you're in a vintage film, that's your call. My best advice, if you're joining a social club, you don't want to totally act on a lighter for a buddy that may not take off, eh. Didn't your red wine chilled and paired with that? Okay!
When to Stop
Don't push it? I call stick stop "I've only had two to three with two cigars but I'm good I did. Remember, this is supposed to be fun. If you're not getting any enjoyment, set it off because you're too weak or not enjoying it, set it aside and return to it later. If you're feeling it—lovely! Your lips too, may I suggest a kind of cut if rigorous flavor thick shock alike to taffy. Drawing harder is also good for this.
Final Thoughts
Let it be graceful, don't stuff it or end. Finito. We now to a little bit of tradition where I like to pay my respects to the flame and the hours spent getting that cigar. Now, tobacco seed to the perfectly rolled stick I have to be able to smoke in the UK. They say like 250 pairs of hands "touch" your cigar before you do. So once I've taken my last pull I generally say thank you for the wonderful journey and place it in an ashtray and that should be the end of every glass partner!
Proper Cigar Storage
Once you've discovered your passion for premium cigars, proper storage becomes essential. A quality humidor maintains the ideal humidity and temperature conditions that preserve your cigars' flavor, aroma, and construction. Whether you're building a modest collection or planning for long-term aging, investing in reliable storage ensures every cigar you enjoy will be at its absolute best.
A well-maintained humidor protects your investment and enhances your cigar experience by keeping each stick in optimal condition, ready to deliver the exceptional quality and complex flavors that make premium cigars so special.
Preserve Your Premium Cigars
Store your collection with confidence in our spacious, reliable humidor—designed to maintain perfect conditions for up to 1200 cigars.
Shop Cigar HumidorElevate your cigar enjoyment with proper storage and care—because quality cigars deserve quality preservation.